Hoagie Haven

Reviews

• Joan S.

  star star star star star_border 3 June 2026

  I had the Sanchez Sandwich and it was so good! It has crispy chicken, French fries, and sauce. The place was packed when I got there but it moved relatively quickly.
  Limited seating area.
  
  The employees are nice and pleasant when they took out order.

• Patrick H.

  star star star star star_border 26 May 2026

  This place is probably is one of the best hoagie joints (for those who aren't from the area, hoagie = sub) that I've ever been to. Small m&p store in Princeton, and they have hoagies of all flavors. However, their specialty hoagies are probably the ones you want to try, which are a mix of amazing ingredients. These ingredients are basically things that will cause a heart attack, like mozzarella sticks, fries, bacon, etc. It's similar to fat sandwiches. I got the Wake Up Call, which has Cheesesteak, Bacon, Eggs, hash Brown, and Pork Roll all in a sub, haha. I also had fried boneless wings in their Sanchez sauce, which was absolutely amazing. The Sanchez seems to be one of their popular selections. The price is decent and not too expensive. Finally, their half size is a good 6-8" long, so it's great for 1 person. Their full size is HUGE, and probably can't be finished in a sitting.
  
  This place would've gotten a 5/5 if it weren't for a few things. Because it's a small store in a college town, you'd expect that it can get VERY busy. We came on a Friday night at 8-9pm, and it was already busy. I was told it gets worse later in the night. If you go to their website, you can see a homepage animation of the store with it packed. There's no organized line or system/way of them taking orders. It can get very confusing and you might lose your order. Not much of a space to eat inside as well, just a few bar tops. Of note, they do not accept cards.

• Maria V.

  star star star star star_border 25 May 2026

  We order from here sometimes ( at work)
  
  I got a half of a chicken cheesesteak with blue cheese and was not bad
  
  It's always good to have another option when we order lunch at work

• Michael S.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 22 May 2026

  I went in and ordered the #3 (Ham, salami & provolone). It was half a step up from Subway. I watched the guy who took my order put 2 flat slices of ham, 2 slices of salami and 2 slices of cheese on the bread. All pre-sliced and not top quality. Brown lettuce, tomato, onion, OV & spices. The bread was just OK, and for $5, I guess you get what you pay for. Totally edible, but Jersey Mikes puts it to shame...

• Jack K.

  star star star star star 7 May 2026

  I've been eating here since 1984, and this sandwich shop has never disappointed.  The size of their sandwiches has remained giant, but my appetite has decreased. Back in 1984 before the whole fat sandwich craze, my favorites were the pizza cheesesteak, the sausage omelette and the eggplant parm hoagies.  I used to eat 2 whole hoagies in one sitting by myself.  Now with age, I can only manage 1/2 of a hoagie by myself.  That's how big these hoagies are.  A whole can feed 2 average people.
  
  With the advent of fat sandwiches, I now enjoy the Body Bag and the Wake Up Call.  Just tried the Phat Veg and that is delicious, too.
  
  Highly recommend!